10 Reasons Washer is Disqualified

10 Reasons Washer is Disqualified 

I am writing to you because many of your churches have been substantially influenced by, or have meaningful connections with, HeartCry Missionary Society and Paul Washer.

I am increasingly concerned that there may be a substantial effort to avoid, suppress, or prevent meaningful examination of the matters I am about to discuss. I have attempted to raise these concerns with numerous influential leaders within the conservative Reformed community in hopes of bringing appropriate accountability and independent examination to these issues. In many instances, however, those I have contacted have either declined to communicate with me, declined to address the concerns themselves, or declined to bring them before people or institutions capable of meaningfully examining them.

That is why I am writing directly to you. Given your churches' connections to HeartCry, I believe this information may be relevant to your ministries and may warrant independent investigation by pastors who are in a position to evaluate these matters biblically and responsibly.

I am writing to lay out a number of serious concerns regarding Paul Washer and his present qualification for ministry. I believe many of these concerns are potentially disqualifying in themselves. Taken collectively, however, I believe they make an exceptionally strong case that Washer is presently disqualified and should cease public ministry unless and until these matters are adequately addressed.

Before considering these concerns, it is important to understand them in light of the unusually strict standards Washer has spent decades applying to professing Christians. A central theme of his teaching has been that genuine conversion necessarily produces an enduring transformation and that someone who continues in a pattern of unrepentant sin has serious reason to question his salvation. Washer has also made extraordinarily severe estimates concerning how few professing evangelicals—and even conservative Reformed Christians—are genuinely converted.

An example of the theological framework relevant to these concerns can be seen in a 2006 HeartCry question-and-answer panel. During the discussion, one speaker states:

“It is useless praying if you have unconfessed sin in your heart and you are aware of that.”

The point is then summarized:

“Sin in the heart, God doesn’t listen.”

The discussion goes even further, arguing that someone praying while knowingly harboring unconfessed sin is effectively praying to an idol rather than to God, concluding that such prayer “would have to be prayer to your own idol, not to the true God that you know you’re sinning against.”

Significantly, no distinction is made based upon the seriousness of the particular sin. The principle is stated categorically in terms of known, unconfessed sin itself. The clear implication appears to be that any knowingly unconfessed sin, regardless of its relative severity, obstructs a believer's fellowship with God.

I begin here because this provides important context for everything that follows. I am not arguing that Christian ministers must attain sinless perfection. Rather, the question is whether Washer has demonstrated prolonged patterns of serious conduct inconsistent with the very standards of repentance, holiness, integrity, church accountability, and Christian character that he has spent decades applying so rigorously to others.

If Washer has insisted that other professing Christians examine themselves this carefully, then it is reasonable to examine his own conduct according to those same principles. The following concerns should therefore be considered not merely in isolation, but cumulatively.

1. Church membership and accountability

My understanding is that Paul Washer has spent approximately four years without meaningful local-church membership, dating roughly to HeartCry's relocation to the Roanoke area in 2022. This is especially significant because HeartCry has historically insisted that it is not simply an independent parachurch ministry, but operates under local-church authority and accountability. HeartCry's published standard states that “each staff member of HeartCry Missionary Society is a member in good standing of a local church,” and has described its central-office staff as personally known by their elders and subject to the church's teaching, counsel, and discipline.

I have confirmed through conversations with individuals familiar with Washer's previous church situation that when he left the church with which he had been associated around 2022, his membership was not transferred to another local church, nor was HeartCry's accountability transferred to another church.

Since then, I have traced Washer's attendance through a succession of churches in the Roanoke area. Based on my conversations with representatives of these churches, I have been unable to establish that Washer became a member of any of them.

Given that Washer appears to have spent the last four years moving among churches and attending several for substantial periods, it is exceedingly difficult to reconcile this history with the suggestion that he was simultaneously a member in good standing of some other church throughout that period. Meaningful membership in a 1689 Reformed Baptist church, or virtually any conservative church that takes membership seriously, ordinarily entails actually gathering with that congregation and living under the pastoral oversight of its elders.

Importantly, this period did not involve a withdrawal from ministry. During these same years, Washer continued an extensive national and international preaching ministry—speaking at major conferences, guest-preaching at numerous churches, traveling on behalf of HeartCry, and continuing his public leadership role. The concern therefore is not simply that someone needed a reasonable period to find another church after relocating. The allegation is that Washer continued an extensive public ministry for years while apparently remaining outside the very form of local-church membership and pastoral accountability that he and HeartCry have insisted is essential for those engaged in ministry.

I have more recently been told by a pastor with a personal relationship with Washer that Washer's supposed elders have represented him as currently being a member of an established church. If so, it should be straightforward to substantiate. Why, then, does HeartCry refuse to answer basic questions about this from a faithful donor church that has supported the ministry for more than five years?

And even if Washer has recently become a member of a church, that would not answer the historical question: what church held his membership, and which elders exercised meaningful pastoral oversight over him, during the preceding years?

2. His departures from previous churches and their assessments of him

I am also concerned about an apparent pattern involving Washer's relationships with churches that knew him and HeartCry most substantially. This is particularly important under Washer's own stated standard. Writing about missionary qualifications, Washer stated:

“They must have a solid testimony and a strong reputation among the churches and elders who know them best.”

Washer has likewise explicitly rejected the attitude, “I'm accountable to God, I'm not accountable to the church,”describing such thinking as unbiblical. He has also taught that evaluating a minister's life and qualifications over time is something only the local church has the ability to do.

Washer and HeartCry were associated for substantial periods with churches in both Alabama and Virginia. Based upon conversations I have had with individuals familiar with these relationships, Washer's departures appear to have involved significant difficulties, and meaningful relationships with previous church leadership do not appear to have continued afterward.

This becomes more significant because, when a subsequent church in the Roanoke area considered Washer for membership, I was informed that it contacted two of his previous churches and received negative reports from both. Washer attended the Roanoke-area church for approximately a year and was considered for membership, but the relationship ultimately ended without Washer becoming a member and, based upon what I have been told, did not end positively.

I have also confirmed that between his periods at the Alabama and Virginia churches, Washer attended another Alabama church for approximately a year and a half. I have received secondhand information suggesting that this relationship may also have ended negatively, although I have not independently confirmed the circumstances and therefore do not present that as established fact.

An unfavorable departure from one church would not by itself establish ministerial disqualification. But if multiple churches that knew Washer over extended periods experienced difficult relationships with him—and two previous churches subsequently provided negative reports when another congregation considered him for membership—the pattern deserves serious investigation.

The significance is heightened by Washer's own standard. If missionaries “must have a solid testimony and a strong reputation among the churches and elders who know them best,” then considerable weight should be given to the assessments of churches and elders who actually knew Washer over extended periods.

The concern is therefore not simply that Washer has experienced disagreements with churches. It is whether his history demonstrates the kind of solid testimony, good reputation, peaceful relationships, and meaningful submission to local-church accountability that HeartCry itself requires of those engaged in missionary ministry.

3. The statistical claims used in the Shocking Youth Message

I have serious concerns regarding the statistical claims Washer used in the Shocking Youth Message to support his broader argument about false conversion within American evangelicalism. In the sermon, Washer appeals to surveys and polling—including Barna and Gallup—and argues in substance that the morality of professing Christians is essentially indistinguishable from that of unbelievers, specifically referencing matters such as abortion, fornication, and divorce.

These were not presented merely as Washer's personal impressions. He appealed directly to statistical research and strongly challenged those who questioned him, stating that he was willing to show people the data supporting his claims.

Yet, to my knowledge, Washer or HeartCry has never publicly identified the specific studies underlying these assertions or demonstrated that the studies actually support the sweeping conclusion presented in the sermon. The relevant questions should be straightforward to answer: What Barna, Gallup, or other studies was Washer citing? What populations were surveyed? What were the actual statistics? And did those studies really demonstrate that the morality of the evangelical church was essentially “the exact same” as that of unbelievers?

I am not arguing that a preacher must footnote every statement made from the pulpit. The concern is that Washer made extraordinarily consequential claims about the spiritual condition of millions of professing Christians, explicitly grounded those claims in statistical evidence, and indicated that he could substantiate them when challenged.

I have been attempting to obtain clarification from HeartCry regarding controversial statements like these for approximately a year and a half, with particularly persistent efforts over the past six months. Despite those repeated attempts, I have not received any response whatsoever from HeartCry addressing these concerns.

Given the enormous reach of the Shocking Youth Message and the continuing influence of these claims, if the underlying evidence does not actually support what Washer said, I believe a public clarification or correction would be appropriate.

4. His statements regarding false conversion

Washer has made extraordinarily severe estimates concerning the spiritual condition of professing Christians, including statements suggesting that approximately 98% of evangelicals, 90% of Southern Baptists, and 80% of even conservative Reformed church members may be lost.

I recognize that the precise wording, context, and sourcing of these percentages should themselves be independently verified. But if Washer made these estimates substantially as reported, they represent extraordinarily severe judgments concerning the spiritual condition of enormous numbers of professing Christians.

I have also spoken multiple times with a longtime friend of Washer who has indicated to me that Washer has changed his views on at least some of these matters. If so, I believe that raises a reasonable question: What specifically has Washer changed his mind about, and does he believe that any of his older, widely circulated teaching requires clarification or correction?

I have attempted for approximately a year and a half to obtain clarification from HeartCry regarding these matters. Despite my repeated efforts, HeartCry has not provided me with any response addressing these questions.

These statements matter because they establish the severity of the standard Washer has publicly applied to others. If he has repeatedly warned professing Christians that prolonged patterns inconsistent with biblical Christianity may demonstrate false conversion, then consistency requires that the standards of repentance, holiness, integrity, and perseverance he has applied so rigorously to others also be applied seriously to his own life and ministry.

5. HeartCry's characterization of Kevin Hite's position

I remain deeply concerned about how HeartCry characterized Kevin Hite's position when informing donors of his 2020 arrest. HeartCry described Hite as an “office administrator.” It has since been confirmed that Hite had actually served as HeartCry's Director of Operations for approximately ten years. He was not simply a low-level administrative employee, as HeartCry's description could reasonably have led donors to believe. He was a longstanding senior figure within the organization and also occupied an officially recognized leadership position at the church with which HeartCry was associated.

Against the gravity of those circumstances, HeartCry's description of Hite merely as an “office administrator” is particularly troubling. Contemporary reporting described him much differently: as HeartCry's former operations director, a “mission society leader,” and a “church leader.”

I can personally attest to the impression HeartCry's wording created for me. When I originally learned about the situation through HeartCry's disclosure, the description “office administrator” gave me the impression that Hite occupied a relatively minor administrative position. I did not understand that he had actually served as HeartCry's Director of Operations for approximately a decade and simultaneously occupied a recognized leadership position at the church.

I want to be precise about the allegation I am making. I am not arguing that HeartCry was responsible for Hite's crimes, nor does his seniority establish that HeartCry knew about or enabled his conduct. My concern is narrower: Did HeartCry give its donors an accurate picture of the institutional significance of the man whose arrest it was disclosing?

If Hite served for approximately ten years as HeartCry's Director of Operations and simultaneously occupied a recognized church leadership position, then describing him to donors merely as an “office administrator” appears to have substantially understated his actual position.

Given the extraordinarily serious circumstances being disclosed, I believe that distinction matters. It raises the broader question of whether HeartCry's communication gave donors the fullest and clearest understanding of what had occurred, or whether its wording had the effect of minimizing the institutional significance of the individual involved.

6. The claim regarding Washer's current church membership and the representation that these concerns would be addressed upon his return from Peru

As noted above, a pastor who has a personal relationship with Washer told me that he received confirmation from Washer's supposed elders that Washer is presently a member of an established local church. This conflicts with numerous previous sources who have told me that Washer is currently planting a church, although I recognize that both accounts could conceivably be true.

This should be exceptionally easy to clarify. If Washer is presently a member in good standing, personally known by his elders, and meaningfully accountable to them, why has HeartCry refused to provide basic confirmation of this to a faithful donor church asking precisely these questions? And even if he has recently become a member, that does not answer where his membership and meaningful pastoral accountability existed during the preceding four years.

I also had an approximately two-hour conversation with an elder at a church closely connected with HeartCry. At the conclusion of our conversation, he told me that he agreed with all of my concerns and subsequently relayed them to people close to Washer. I was then told that these matters would be addressed when Washer returned from Peru.

Washer has now returned, or is presently returning, from Peru, yet HeartCry continues to refuse to answer basic questions from its own donors.

HeartCry should therefore clarify two straightforward matters: Is Washer presently a member in good standing of an established local church, and does HeartCry intend to substantively address the concerns it represented would be addressed upon his return?

If no substantive response is forthcoming, it is reasonable to ask whether these representations were accurate in the first place. I do not want to characterize either as a lie without sufficient evidence, but continued refusal to provide straightforward answers inevitably raises that question.

7. HeartCry's refusal to answer the donors and missionaries it claims to serve

HeartCry's own description of its relationship to its donors and missionaries makes its refusal to address these concerns particularly troubling. HeartCry states:

“There are only two human heroes in the HeartCry story: the missionaries who go down into the abyss to rescue the perishing, and the donors who hold the rope for them. HeartCry is merely the rope. We are stewards serving two heroes and their God.”

HeartCry likewise states that its team exists to “serve the missionaries and the donors.”

If HeartCry truly regards itself as merely the rope—a steward serving the missionaries who go and the donors who hold that rope—why is it withholding answers from both groups?

As discussed above, a faithful donor church that has supported HeartCry for more than five years has raised straightforward questions concerning Washer's church membership and accountability and has been unable to obtain meaningful answers.

But this problem is not limited to donors. I have had lengthy conversations, some lasting one to two hours, with several missionaries who faithfully labor with HeartCry. These missionaries expressed concerns regarding a number of the same matters raised in this email, and at least one wanted them meaningfully addressed for the sake of his own conscience and ministry.

My understanding from these conversations is that they repeatedly attempted to obtain answers through their coordinators and directly from HeartCry's headquarters, yet for months they were unable to obtain substantive answers to these concerns.

That creates a striking contradiction. HeartCry publicly describes the missionaries and donors as the two human heroes of its story and itself as merely their servant and steward. Yet when members of both groups raise questions concerning the integrity, accountability, and leadership of the organization they are sacrificing to support or represent, they apparently cannot obtain straightforward answers.

If HeartCry is truly “merely the rope,” then the people going down into the well and the people holding that rope should not be kept in the dark about significant questions concerning the integrity and accountability of the organization connecting them.

8. HeartCry's financial and methodological representations

I also have concerns regarding HeartCry's financial and fundraising representations. HeartCry states that approximately 85% of donations go to the field, yet when I examined its publicly available financial documents, my calculation appeared closer to 70–75%. I recognize that nonprofit accounting classifications can be complicated, but this raises a straightforward question: How is the 85% figure calculated? Are salaries and expenses for missions coordinators, who spend relatively little time physically on the field, included as money that “goes to the field”? If so, I believe that should be clearly explained to donors.

I am also concerned about HeartCry's repeated identification with George Müller's philosophy of trusting God to provide rather than soliciting funds. The broader principle implied by HeartCry's promotional material is one of avoiding human manipulation, pragmatism, and strategic fundraising techniques and instead trusting God to provide.

My own experience raises questions about whether HeartCry still operates consistently with that philosophy. Over approximately two weeks, I left five messages asking to speak with someone about HeartCry's missions philosophy and received no response. On my final message, I added that I was interested in making a significant contribution. I received a return call almost immediately. When I asked the donor representative about this, he told me that my message had likely been filtered by the receptionist on that basis.

Yet when I actually spoke with this representative and raised the concerns outlined in this email, he refused to forward or escalate them for further review and appeared substantially uninterested in addressing them. The conversation instead remained focused on the kind of brief interaction that would help a potential donor determine whether to contribute.

I have also found examples of this same representative reaching out to churches that had donated to HeartCry despite, as I understand it, those churches not having provided contact information or sought a relationship with HeartCry. He thanked them and attempted to establish an ongoing relationship. There is nothing inherently wrong with such donor cultivation; it resembles conventional nonprofit advancement. But that is precisely the question: if HeartCry is cultivating donors and prioritizing potential significant contributions in ways characteristic of conventional fundraising, is it still accurate to distinguish itself on the basis of a Müller-style approach?

The contrast is especially striking when HeartCry reportedly fails to answer substantive questions from its missionaries and long-term supporters, while a reference to a potentially significant contribution can produce an almost immediate response.

I am not alleging that donor cultivation itself is improper. I am asking whether HeartCry's actual financial and fundraising practices accurately reflect the distinctive philosophy it continues to present publicly.

9. Truthfulness and exaggeration

Washer himself has testified that after his conversion he continued to struggle with lying and exaggeration. A person's admission of a historical struggle obviously does not establish present dishonesty, and I do not present it that way.

Nevertheless, this testimony becomes relevant when considered alongside the separate concerns raised throughout this email regarding the accuracy of statistical claims, organizational representations, church accountability, and other statements. If the evidence establishes a continuing pattern of exaggeration or inaccurate representation, Washer's own testimony regarding his historical struggle in precisely this area becomes relevant context.

The question should ultimately be resolved by evidence rather than assumption. But given the number of representations discussed above that appear to require clarification, I believe the issue of truthfulness warrants examination rather than dismissal.

10. Character and elder qualifications

Finally, I have received firsthand accounts from numerous people who have known or interacted with Washer—both people who regard him favorably and people who are critical of him—that raise questions about whether his conduct consistently meets the biblical qualifications of an elder. The concerns described to me include disproportionate anger, verbally aggressive behavior, harshness, quarrelsomeness, and difficulty maintaining peaceful relationships.

This is particularly important because HeartCry itself applies elder qualifications to its preaching and teaching missionaries. HeartCry requires such missionaries to meet the qualifications of an elder in 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1, even though a missionary, evangelist, or church planter may not technically occupy the office of pastor in a local church. In other words, under HeartCry's own methodology, the biblical character requirements of an elder remain applicable to those engaged in this kind of missionary ministry.

That makes the standard articulated at the 2006 HeartCry conference particularly relevant. As discussed at the beginning of this email, the panel taught categorically that knowingly harboring unconfessed sin obstructs fellowship with God—going so far as to say that such prayer is effectively directed toward an idol rather than the true God. No distinction was made according to the relative severity of the known sin.

If that is the standard applied to the ordinary Christian life, the implications for a minister whom HeartCry's own methodology requires to be elder-qualified are even more significant. The question is not whether Washer must be sinlessly perfect. It is whether recurring, known patterns of anger, harshness, quarrelsomeness, exaggeration, or other inappropriate conduct can persist over substantial periods while he continues to satisfy qualifications specifically requiring that a minister be above reproach, self-controlled, respectable, gentle, and not quarrelsome. By Washer's own unusually rigorous framework, repeated conduct in these areas cannot simply be dismissed as personality differences.

There is also a public dimension to this concern. Anyone who has listened extensively to Washer's preaching will recognize how frequently he reinforces doctrines or Christian principles by sharply criticizing those who disagree with him. At times this extends even to secondary doctrines and practices on which Scripture does not clearly prescribe a single position or method.

For years, I interpreted this charitably. I regarded Washer's critical spirit as evidence of genuine love for truth, and what could appear to be condescension as frustration and sincere passion for the ways of the Lord. There remains a legitimate charitable interpretation: Washer is willing to say difficult things that many ministers may avoid out of fear of influential evangelical leaders or their congregations.

But boldness and courage do not eliminate the equally biblical requirements of gentleness, self-control, freedom from quarrelsomeness, and love toward those with whom one disagrees. A pattern of reinforcing one's position by attacking or speaking condescendingly toward those who disagree—particularly on secondary matters—should therefore be evaluated not merely as preaching style but in light of these character qualifications.

To be fair to Washer, I also know that when he recognizes that he has behaved inappropriately, he genuinely apologizes for his conduct. That should be acknowledged. I do not know whether this consistently occurs. And even if he regularly apologizes afterward, repentance after an incident does not by itself resolve the separate question of whether a recurring pattern remains compatible with the established character qualifications required of an elder.

The ultimate question, therefore, is not whether Washer has a strong personality, preaches forcefully, occasionally behaves wrongly, or genuinely repents afterward. It is whether the cumulative evidence demonstrates a persistent pattern of anger, harshness, quarrelsomeness, condescension, exaggeration or inaccurate representation, and difficult relationshipsthat conflicts with several of the qualifications HeartCry itself insists a missionary must meet.

Conclusion

I recognize that some of these matters involve disputed claims and that Washer and HeartCry may possess explanations or information that I do not have. I am willing to hear those explanations and to correct anything I have gotten wrong. But that is precisely why substantive answers and independent investigation are needed.

Nor do I believe every allegation above should simply be assumed true because someone reported it to me. I have tried to distinguish between matters directly confirmed to me by pastors, elders, church staff, missionaries, and other individuals; conclusions I have drawn from those conversations; and information I have received secondhand that still requires independent verification.

The concerns should therefore be investigated rather than simply accepted. But neither should they be dismissed individually without considering the cumulative picture.

The overall pattern includes questions concerning approximately four years of apparent absence from meaningful church membership; difficult departures from churches that knew Washer substantially; negative assessments reportedly provided by previous churches; unresolved questions concerning influential statistical claims; questions concerning HeartCry's public, financial, and fundraising representations; its characterization of a former senior leader; concerns regarding truthfulness and character; and its continuing unwillingness to provide straightforward answers to donors and missionaries.

Most importantly, these matters must be considered against the standards Washer and HeartCry themselves have articulated. Washer has taught that missionaries must possess “a solid testimony and a strong reputation among the churches and elders who know them best.” HeartCry requires its preaching and teaching missionaries to meet biblical elder qualifications and emphasizes meaningful local-church accountability. Washer has spent decades calling professing Christians to examine themselves rigorously for evidence of repentance, holiness, and perseverance.

Given those standards, I do not believe it is unreasonable to ask that the same degree of scrutiny be applied seriously and transparently to Washer's own life and ministry.

I am not asking anyone simply to accept my conclusions. Many of these claims are independently verifiable by speaking directly with the pastors, elders, churches, missionaries, and individuals involved. My hope is that these matters will be investigated carefully, that anything I have gotten wrong will be corrected, and that anything that proves true will be dealt with honestly and appropriately.

Caleb Cox 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

BREAKING NEWS: Serious Allegations Against Paul Washer and HeartCry Missionary Society

Accountability for Ministries who have Endorsed Washer/Peters