Letter to Tommy Walls
This is an email exchange between myself and Tommy Walls, an elder at Grace Baptist Church in Conway, Arkansas, a congregation with significant connections to Paul Washer and HeartCry Missionary Society.
Ryan Bush, a HeartCry regional coordinator, also serves as an elder at the church. Additionally, Jeff Johnson serves both as a trustee of HeartCry Missionary Society and as the lead elder of Grace Baptist Church.
Given these overlapping leadership positions and institutional relationships, Tommy Walls has significant connections to individuals involved in HeartCry's leadership. While these connections do not necessarily establish that he is an authorized representative of HeartCry, they provide important context for understanding the significance of our correspondence.
I sent Tommy Walls two emails on consecutive days. Approximately three or four days later, Tommy responded. I replied to his response immediately, but as of this writing, approximately five to six weeks have passed without any further response from him.
Approximately two months ago, Tommy Walls told me during a telephone conversation that once Paul Washer returned from Peru, my concerns would be addressed individually.
However, as you will see in the subsequent email exchange, Tommy later stated, "I can't hold them to that."
Hey Tommy,
It’s Caleb. We spoke about a month ago regarding Paul Washer and my concerns related to his ministry. As I recall our conversation, you agreed with all—or at least the vast majority—of the concerns I raised. I wanted to summarize them again and ask for your help in getting these matters addressed.
Church membership and accountability. My understanding is that Paul Washer is not currently a member of a local church, or at minimum spent several years without church membership, despite HeartCry's own standards emphasizing that its missionaries and staff are to be members of local churches in good standing, known by their elders, and under meaningful local-church accountability.
His departures from previous churches. My understanding is that Washer left his past three significant church relationships on negative terms. This is especially relevant given Washer's own teaching that the people who know a missionary best—particularly his local church—are best positioned to evaluate his character and qualifications for ministry.
The statistics used in the Shocking Youth Message. To my knowledge, Washer has never corrected his claims concerning studies supposedly demonstrating essentially no moral difference between professing Christians and unbelievers across moral issues. He has also strongly challenged those who question these statistics, saying in substance that he can prove those who doubt them wrong.
His statements regarding false conversion. Washer has made extraordinarily severe estimates concerning the spiritual condition of professing Christians, including statements suggesting that only approximately 2% of evangelicals and roughly 20% of even conservative Reformed church members may actually be converted. Given the severity of the standards Washer has publicly applied to others for decades, I believe his own life and ministry should be evaluated with corresponding seriousness.
HeartCry's characterization of Kevin Hitt's position. I remain deeply concerned about how HeartCry characterized Kevin Hitt's role when addressing his arrest for sexual abuse of a minor. HeartCry referred to him as an "office administrator," whereas my research indicates that he had served in the substantially more significant position of Director of Operations for approximately a decade. I believe describing him merely as an office administrator materially understated his role within HeartCry.
The claim regarding Washer's current church membership. I have been told that RBNet pastor David Dowdy confirmed with Washer's supposed elders that Washer is presently a member of an established local church. I have serious questions about this claim. If Washer's membership and accountability have actually been verified, why won't Adam Burrell provide Damon Joseph with basic confirmation of that fact? This should be one of the simplest concerns for HeartCry to resolve.
HeartCry's refusal to substantively address these questions. I have been raising these concerns for several months, yet HeartCry has repeatedly declined or failed to provide substantive answers to straightforward questions regarding Washer's church membership, accountability, and qualifications for ministry.
HeartCry's financial representations. I also have concerns regarding HeartCry's claim that approximately 85% of donations go to the field when my understanding of the financial figures puts the number closer to 75%. If my calculation is incorrect, HeartCry should be able to explain clearly how the 85% figure is derived.
Washer's own testimony regarding lying and exaggeration. Washer himself has testified that after his conversion he continued to struggle with lying and exaggeration. In light of the other concerns above, I believe that history is relevant and warrants careful consideration rather than dismissal.
Character and elder qualifications. Finally, I have received firsthand accounts from numerous people who have known or interacted with Washer—both people who regard him favorably and people who are critical of him—that raise serious questions about whether his conduct consistently meets the biblical qualifications of an elder. The concerns described to me include disproportionate or sudden anger, verbally aggressive or abusive behavior, harshness, quarrelsomeness, and difficulty maintaining peaceful relationships. If these accounts are accurate and represent an ongoing pattern rather than isolated incidents, they bear directly on the biblical requirements that an elder be above reproach, sober-minded, self-controlled, gentle, and not quarrelsome.
I am including Damon Joseph on this email because he reached out to Adam Burrell early last week and has yet to receive a response. Damon's church has faithfully supported HeartCry financially for the past six years, and he is now at the point of considering ending his church's financial support for HeartCry and encouraging others to reconsider their support because these concerns remain unresolved.
When we spoke about a month ago, you told me that you had spoken with two people close to Washer and that they indicated these concerns would be addressed when Paul returned to the United States from Peru. Given that our conversation was approximately four weeks ago, I assume Paul has either returned by now or will be returning shortly.
Was Jeff Johnson one of the two people you spoke with? Given that Jeff is a board member of HeartCry, it seems to me that he also bears responsibility for ensuring that serious concerns regarding the ministry and its leadership are addressed, particularly if Adam Burrell and other HeartCry representatives are unwilling to provide answers.
Would you please speak directly with Damon and provide him with whatever information you can regarding these concerns? Damon is a fellow RBNet pastor, and I believe a direct conversation between the two of you would be particularly appropriate and helpful.
If I have misremembered any part of our previous conversation or overstated the extent to which you agreed with these concerns, please correct me. My purpose in putting this in writing is to make sure the issues are stated clearly and that the people responsible for HeartCry have an opportunity to address them directly.
Thank you,
Caleb
Hey Tommy,
I also wanted to add something regarding my heart behind all of this.
My desire throughout this entire situation is ultimately reconciliation. I believe we need to love one another rather than constantly judging one another and merely demanding repentance. That being said, there is not even the slightest question in my mind—and numerous pastors I have spoken with have expressed agreement with me—that Paul Washer is disqualified according to the very standard he has preached and applied to others for decades.
One example comes from the 2006 HeartCry conference, where an extraordinarily strict understanding of known, unrepentant sin was presented: that knowingly cherishing sin blocks fellowship with God, and that attempting to pray while knowingly holding onto that sin amounts to approaching a conception of God inconsistent with His true character. The basic principle presented was that fellowship with God remains broken until the particular known sin is repented of.
I personally believe that is an extraordinarily strict standard for defining the normative Christian life. Nevertheless, if that is the standard Washer and HeartCry have preached to others, then they must be willing to have Washer's own life and ministry evaluated according to the same standard. If Washer himself has knowingly remained in patterns of unrepentant sin that violate the standard he has spent decades preaching, then by his own standard I do not see how his continued qualification for ministry can be defended.
I also believe there comes a point when the problem can no longer reasonably be attributed to a single leader. We saw something analogous with G3: when serious problems emerged, there was an effort to distinguish the organization from the failures of its principal leader. But the question inevitably becomes whether the problems extend more deeply into the leadership structure and culture of the organization itself.
I believe that question now needs to be asked seriously about HeartCry. My conclusion, based upon the information I have gathered, is that Washer has been unqualified or disqualified for a substantial period of time. If HeartCry's senior leadership and trustees knew of serious, disqualifying problems and nevertheless concealed them, enabled them, misrepresented them, or refused to exercise appropriate accountability, then their own qualifications and complicity must be examined as well. If that pattern extends throughout the organization's governing leadership, I believe there is a legitimate question as to whether HeartCry should continue to exist in its present form at all.
That responsibility also extends, in my view, to ministries and churches with meaningful relationships to HeartCry and its leadership—including RBNet and Grace Baptist Church of Conway through Jeff Johnson's position as a HeartCry trustee. Ephesians 5:11 commands Christians to "take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them." I believe organizations that become aware of credible evidence of serious wrongdoing have a responsibility to examine it rather than simply distance themselves from the controversy or remain silent.
My desire is not destruction for destruction's sake. I want truth, repentance, reconciliation, and restoration wherever restoration is biblically possible. But reconciliation cannot mean overlooking serious wrongdoing, and love cannot require silence. If these concerns are mistaken, I want them answered and corrected. If they are substantially true, however, I believe the appropriate response is confession, repentance, accountability, and whatever consequences Scripture requires.
Caleb
Thanks for your reply, Tommy.
Yes, I will admit that over the last several weeks I have developed a fixation on exposing what I believe to be serious hypocrisy in Paul Washer's ministry. Paul was my biggest role model for approximately five years after I was saved. I recognize that ideally my primary role models should have been people I actually knew personally, but be that as it may, I listened to hours and hours of Paul's preaching. There were individual sermons I listened to ten or fifteen times. I hung on virtually every word he said, took what he said to the bank, and believed he was one of the godliest and most biblically knowledgeable men alive.
Because of that, what I have learned over the past several months has been extremely jarring and disorienting for me. I am sorry for sending you so many emails, but I hope you can understand the place I am coming from.
I also apologize if I mischaracterized our conversation. I genuinely appreciated you spending two hours listening to my concerns a month ago and forwarding them to HeartCry leadership. My impression was that you largely or entirely agreed that my concerns were serious and that, based upon the information I had gathered, you understood why I was frustrated and felt mistreated by HeartCry.
I subsequently said that you "explicitly agreed with all of my concerns." That was an overstatement, and I apologize for it. I cannot remember your exact words, and I should not have characterized your position that strongly. The bottom line is that throughout our two-hour conversation, it came across to me that what I was sharing made sense to you, that you considered it serious, and that you believed it was reasonable for me to be frustrated given the information I had. If that was not the posture you intended to communicate, then I apologize for misunderstanding you.
I am after the truth. I will also admit that sometimes, particularly when I am frustrated, I exaggerate something or make an overstatement. If someone calls me on that and they are correct, I will admit it.
Similarly, when you texted me the day after our conversation, I came away with the impression not only that you had communicated my concerns to HeartCry leadership but that you intended, to whatever degree you reasonably could, to see that the response you told me was coming actually occurred. If I misunderstood your role or what you intended to communicate, I apologize for that as well.
If you still have our text exchange, I would appreciate it if you could include in your next email a copy of the message you sent me when I asked you for a follow-up. I deleted our conversation when I made an attempt to drop this entire matter, so I no longer have the exact wording.
My recollection may be imperfect, but my understanding of that message, particularly in the context of our two-hour conversation, was that you intended to use whatever influence you reasonably had to press HeartCry for a meaningful response. I understood that to include your position as an elder at Grace Baptist Conway, your relationship as a fellow elder with Jesse Johnson, who serves on HeartCry's board, and your relationships with other people close to HeartCry.
In other words, I did not understand you merely to be passing my concerns along and then having no further involvement. I came away believing that you intended, to the degree reasonably within your influence, to press the issue and hold HeartCry accountable to the response I understood you to be telling me was forthcoming. If I misunderstood your message, I am willing to acknowledge that. That is precisely why I would appreciate seeing the actual text again.
I appreciate knowing that my complaints have now been heard by Paul and HeartCry. Frankly, it is bizarre to me that Paul Washer even knows who I am. Five years ago, I never imagined that I would ever meet him, much less that he would know who I was.
However, your statement regarding Paul's church involvement is worded in a way that still leaves open the very question I originally raised: Is Paul actually a member in good standing of a local church? That was one of my ten concerns. Your statement that he has recently been involved with and preached at a church does not, by itself, answer that question.
I also have difficulty reconciling your categorical statement that Paul and HeartCry are in no way intentionally misleading or defrauding anyone with the Kevin Hitt matter I previously raised. The question there is fairly straightforward: Why was Kevin publicly described as an "office administrator" in connection with his arrest when HeartCry had previously identified him as its Director of Operations? If Paul knew Kevin's actual position, I believe describing him merely as an office administrator materially downplayed his role. If there is an innocent explanation for that discrepancy, I genuinely want to hear it.
Another part of your email confused me. You tell me that Paul has "feet of clay," that he makes mistakes like the rest of us, and that love covers a multitude of sins. What exactly are you acknowledging by saying that? Are you saying that some of the conduct underlying my ten concerns actually occurred and constituted sin? If so, shouldn't we evaluate what that sin was, whether it was known, whether it was repented of, and how that relates to Paul's own teaching about known sin?
You are correct about one thing: I have dug extremely deeply into Paul's life and ministry and have tried to uncover virtually every relevant negative fact I could find. There is a reason for that. I am testing the theological standard that Paul himself has preached.
Paul has taught that known, unconfessed sin obstructs a person's fellowship with God and that a person's prayers will not be heard rightly while that sin is knowingly cherished. So consider the Kevin Hitt example. As I presently understand the evidence, I see three basic possibilities: either describing Kevin as an office administrator rather than Director of Operations was not a knowing misrepresentation; Paul knowingly misrepresented Kevin's role and therefore must be evaluated according to his own teaching concerning known sin; or Paul's teaching about known sin and fellowship with God requires significant qualification.
That is the theological issue I am trying to expose and examine.
I also disagree that HeartCry's lack of response can simply be attributed to repetitive or obsessive emails from me. Even if that explained their unwillingness to engage with me personally, it would not explain their unwillingness to substantively answer Damon Joseph, whose church has financially supported HeartCry and who approached them independently.
Finally, your statement that I am unreasonable and that nothing can appease me is probably the statement in your email that I object to most strongly. That isn't true. If HeartCry can provide evidence and logical arguments that satisfactorily answer the concerns I have raised, I will accept those answers. As I have already acknowledged in this email, when I overstate something or get something wrong, I am willing to correct it.
What I find unreasonable are three things.
First, your claim that I simply want to "trash" Paul Washer or that I have a vendetta against him. I reject that characterization. Paul was my favorite preacher for five years. I admired him enormously. I had no preexisting or natural reason to launch a campaign against him.
Second, I don't believe Paul's conduct can be answered merely by saying that he has feet of clay like the rest of us and appealing to "love covers a multitude of sins." Of course Paul is imperfect. So am I. That isn't the issue. The issue is whether specific allegations are true, whether actual wrongdoing occurred, and whether Paul's own publicly preached standards apply consistently to himself.
Third, the overall tenor of your email gives me the impression that you find most of the allegations and arguments I have raised substantially unpersuasive. If that is the case—if you do not believe the evidence I have presented raises substantial questions about Paul's character, theology, or qualifications—then I am confused about our original conversation.
Why did I come away from our two-hour phone call with the strong impression that you largely agreed with my concerns? Even now, you have said that you believed I had some legitimate concerns. What specifically are those legitimate concerns?
I think it would be helpful for you to identify them for two reasons. First, it might allow us to establish some common ground rather than simply talking past each other. Second, it would help me understand how significantly I misunderstood our original conversation.
I know that over the course of that two-hour conversation I raised numerous concerns—probably a dozen or more separate categories, although many of them related to the same overarching issues. I also recognize that I did most of the talking. Nevertheless, I don't recall a point during that conversation when you substantially challenged what I was telling you, indicated that you didn't understand one of the allegations, or told me that I had not provided enough evidence to support or explain what I was alleging. That is a significant part of why I came away with the impression that you found the substance of what I was presenting persuasive and concerning.
As I acknowledged above, I overstated your position when I subsequently said that you "explicitly agreed with all of my concerns." But my impression at the end of our conversation was nevertheless that you agreed with most, if not nearly all, of the substance of what I had presented. If that impression was substantially mistaken, I genuinely want to understand how and why—and specifically which concerns you did believe were legitimate.
If I am wrong about Paul Washer, show me where I am wrong. I am willing to correct myself and apologize where necessary. But questioning my motives, pointing to my intensity or fixation on this issue, or reminding me that Paul is an imperfect human being does not answer the substance of the concerns I have raised.
What I take the greatest issue with in your email is your statement that you are "not sure how Paul or HeartCry could appease me," that I have become unreasonable, and that apparently nothing would satisfy me. I think that is an utterly absurd characterization of the situation.
How can you conclude that nothing would appease me when, for approximately a year and a half, I have been asking questions that HeartCry has never even attempted to answer? They have not responded to a single one of my phone calls. They have not responded to a single one of my emails. They have not had any discussion or made any attempt to walk through the evidence with me. They have not provided any answers to the allegations I have raised. Nothing.
At least if HeartCry were willing to respond to my questions, even briefly, in a cursory and broad manner—without being willing to engage in a detailed back-and-forth discussion—and largely dismissed my concerns out of hand, I would at least have something to accept or reject. I could at least give them the benefit of the doubt that they had made some attempt to reassure someone who had been one of Paul's most loyal followers and supporters. Instead, I have received nothing.
Obviously, what I would actually prefer is for HeartCry to give me substantive responses to my questions that genuinely come from the heart and are motivated by a desire for both truth and love. From the standpoint of truth, I would hope they would genuinely attempt to understand my point of view and evaluate my concerns according to the evidence, reason, and Scripture. From the standpoint of love, I would hope they would care that someone who has spent hundreds upon hundreds of hours listening to Paul's teaching has become deeply troubled by what he has discovered. I would hope they would be willing to dedicate even a few hours to helping me understand where I may have misunderstood Paul's teaching, his conduct, or the Christian life itself.
I would also appreciate an actual back-and-forth conversation in which we could question one another, challenge one another's reasoning, examine the evidence, and discuss the issues I am raising. I am not asking them to agree with me. I am asking them to engage with me. I am very capable of agreeing to disagree and doing so in love. In fact, I believe the love we have for one another is especially demonstrated in how we treat each other when we disagree.
I had an hour-and-a-half conversation with Jesse Barrington, and he has a great sermon on this very subject. Even if you and the people at HeartCry see these situations entirely differently than I do, I would simply like the dignity of a conversation characterized by transparency, openness, tenderness, and brotherly affection.
I simply want to be treated like a fellow brother in Christ. After a year and a half of receiving no engagement whatsoever, I do not feel that I have been treated that way.
The bottom line is that if HeartCry gave me substantive answers supported by evidence and Scripture, and those answers demonstrated that I was wrong, I would accept that. If I am wrong about half of what I have alleged, I will correct half of it. If I am wrong about all of it, I will correct all of it and apologize. I have no interest in defending an allegation merely because I was the person who made it.
But someone actually has to answer me before it is fair to conclude that no answer could ever satisfy me. That is why I find your characterization so unreasonable. I have spent a year and a half asking for engagement. I am still asking for it now. The fact that I continue asking questions after receiving no substantive answers is not evidence that no answer could appease me. If anything, it demonstrates how badly I have wanted someone to actually address them.
Comments
Post a Comment